The Complex History and Legacy of the Ottoman Empire in the Middle East

TLDR The Ottoman Empire's history in the Middle East is marked by a decline in pluralism, major massacres, and controversial decisions that still impact the region today. From the Armenian Genocide to the displacement of populations, the Ottoman Empire's legacy continues to shape the political and cultural landscape of the Middle East.

Timestamped Summary

00:00 The hosts reflect on the success of their Ottoman series and express their fascination with the history and proximity of the Middle East.
04:41 In the brief window between 1914 and 1924, the fate of many different peoples in the Middle East was decided, including the establishment of Turkey and the lack of a state for the Kurds, with the consequences of these decisions still being felt today.
08:57 The Ottoman Empire had a history of pluralism, but over time, that pluralism diminished, leading to major massacres, including the Armenian Genocide in 1915, which still stirs up controversy and tensions between the Armenian and Turkish diasporas today.
13:20 Ataturk saw the Ottomans as representing backwardness and obscurantism, leading him to ban Sufi music, Sufism, and Ottoman music, but since Erdogan's regime, the Ottomans have become popular again, with shows like Ertugul gaining global success, and Erdogan promoting a political continuum between the Ottoman Empire and modern Turkey.
18:08 Turkey is unlikely to challenge China on the issue of the Uyghur genocide due to their reliance on Chinese money, leaving Uyghur refugees in Turkey uncertain about their future.
23:04 The mass emigration of Turkish tribes into eastern Turkey after the Battle of Manzikert in 1071 led to the displacement of existing Byzantines and the migration of Greeks to the coast, resulting in a complicated global history of migrating tribes and the displacement of populations.
27:22 Gertrude Bell, a brilliant scholar and adventurer, becomes an archaeologist and explorer in the Arab world, gaining acceptance from Arab male society and the patronage of the British High Commissioner, Sir Percy Cox, as she navigates through the Middle East and becomes involved in the political and cultural landscape of the region.
31:28 Gertrude Bell advocates for the creation of a nation state for Iraq and throws her support behind the Hashemite Prince Faisal, but she is also a witness to the RAF bombing and gassing of the Kurds in the 1920s.
35:48 Gertrude Bell's life takes a downward turn after losing support and she eventually dies, possibly by suicide, while Churchill's disturbing quotes about the use of poison gas against the Kurds and his views on other races are highlighted, but despite these flaws, Bell is still seen as fascinating and her writing is praised.
40:06 The podcast ends with the hosts discussing the origin of the term "ottoman" for a piece of furniture and speculating on other potential Ottoman contributions such as yogurt and tulips.
Categories: History

The Complex History and Legacy of the Ottoman Empire in the Middle East

44. The Legacy of the Ottomans, Queen of the Desert, and giant turbans
by Empire

Browse more History