The Validity and Limitations of Personality Tests

TLDR Personality tests like the Myers-Briggs and Enneagram are not reliable indicators for making important life decisions, as they oversimplify complex traits and categorize people into types that may not truly exist. The Big Five personality traits, which provide a distribution of scores for each trait, are considered to be more scientifically valid.

Timestamped Summary

00:00 Personality tests like the Myers-Briggs have become popular and widely used, with some people finding them helpful in understanding themselves and their relationships, while others question their validity.
05:08 Personality tests, like the Myers-Briggs type indicator, categorize people into specific personality types based on traits like extroversion/introversion, sensing/intuition, thinking/feeling, and judging/perceiving.
10:10 The Myers-Briggs personality test is not reliable because people often get different results when taking the test multiple times, and the test oversimplifies complex personality traits into black and white categories.
14:49 The Myers-Briggs personality test oversimplifies complex personality traits and lumps people into the same categories, even if they may act differently.
19:20 Personality tests like the Myers-Briggs are not reliable indicators for making important life decisions, such as choosing a job or a romantic partner.
24:07 Personality tests like the Enneagram and Socionix have similar problems to the Myers-Briggs test, as they often categorize people into types that don't really exist, making them unreliable for making important decisions.
29:41 The Big Five personality traits, which include agreeableness, conscientiousness, openness, extraversion, and neuroticism, are considered to be more scientifically valid than other personality tests because they do not categorize individuals into specific types, but instead provide a distribution of scores for each trait.
34:24 The researchers found that people who score higher in neuroticism are more likely to die sooner and have chronic conditions, while those who are more open tend to live longer; extroverted individuals are more likely to move in with their partners and get married, while being more neurotic is linked to not having great relationships and a higher likelihood of divorce; and being more open is linked to more sexual satisfaction in women.
38:40 Personality generally shifts with age, with conscientiousness, agreeableness, and emotional stability increasing in people's 20s, but then dropping later in life; big life events can also change personality, with some people becoming more emotionally stable after the death of a spouse, and trauma potentially making people more neurotic but also more open and adaptable; a study found that personality coaching interventions can lead to desired personality changes.
42:52 Personality Tests: Who Are You Really? is a podcast episode that explores how personality can change over time and in response to life events, and concludes with a discussion about the fun and informative aspects of personality tests.

Browse more Science