Prompt Cast
The Mississippi Flood of 1927: A Turning Point in the Battle Between Big Government and Small Government Approaches to Crisis
TLDR The devastating Mississippi Flood of 1927 highlighted the debate between big government and small government responses to crises. While President Calvin Coolidge took a hands-off approach, leaving relief efforts to the states and charitable organizations, Secretary of Commerce Herbert Hoover organized relief efforts and addressed the nation, but ultimately failed to fulfill promises to end sharecropping and address racial discrimination.
Timestamped Summary
00:00
The great flood of 1927, which inundated seven states and caused significant damage and displacement, marked an inflection point in the battle between big government and small government approaches to crisis.
07:00
The Mississippi Flood of 1927 caused widespread devastation and displacement as levees broke throughout the Mississippi Valley, particularly in the lower Mississippi River region, resulting in loss of life and destruction of homes and farmland.
12:36
The president at the time, Calvin Coolidge, declined to provide support or visit the flood-affected areas, leaving it up to the states and charitable organizations to handle the crisis, but he did appoint Herbert Hoover to coordinate relief efforts.
17:45
Herbert Hoover, Secretary of Commerce at the time, organized relief efforts for the Mississippi flood and addressed the nation in one of the first ever national radio broadcasts, receiving widespread support and donations from American citizens.
22:50
Rumors and reports of mistreatment of African Americans in American Red Cross relief camps during the Mississippi flood began to surface, leading to concerns that the scandal would spread to the mainstream press and potentially impact Hoover's path to the presidency.
28:15
African Americans in the Red Cross relief camps during the Mississippi flood were treated like slaves, held at gunpoint, subjected to violence, and prevented from leaving, while white planters intentionally left black farmers behind to keep them in debt and ensure a labor force for the plantations.
33:19
Hoover, in an effort to control the narrative and maintain support from African-American voters, created a colored advisory commission to investigate the abuses in the red refugee camps, but when the commission delivered a report detailing the discrimination and abuse, Hoover wanted the incriminating findings removed and instead proposed a revolutionary land resettlement plan that would transition black sharecroppers to landowners.
38:36
Moten played along with Hoover's request to revise the report on the red refugee camps in exchange for a promise from Hoover that could potentially end black sharecropping, which Moten believed was a groundbreaking opportunity for Black Americans.
44:04
Hoover's election as president was seen as an opportunity to end sharecropping in the South, but he ultimately did nothing to fulfill this promise, which led to a cooling of his relationship with black political leaders and a shift in support towards the Democratic Party.
49:59
The aftermath of the 1927 flood revealed that while the physical landscape had changed, the racial and economic systems in the South remained the same, with sharecropping continuing and African Americans still facing discrimination and mistreatment.
Categories:
History
Society & Culture
