The Lizzie Borden Murder Case: Debunking the Nursery Rhyme

TLDR This episode delves into the famous murder case of Lizzie Borden, exploring the background, evidence, and trial. Despite being acquitted of the murders, Lizzie Borden faced social ostracism and died alone, leaving doubts about her innocence.

Timestamped Summary

00:00 This episode is about the famous murder case of Lizzie Borden, debunking the popular nursery rhyme associated with it.
04:43 This section introduces the setting of the Lizzie Borden murder case, describing the house where the murders took place and the socioeconomic background of the family.
09:27 Lizzie Borden and her sister had a strained relationship with their stepmother, and their father kept the house locked all the time due to a previous burglary that was believed to have been committed by Lizzie.
14:16 Lizzie Borden's father sold rental properties to her and her sister for a dollar, but they later sold it back to him for a 2,400% increase; the night before the murder, their uncle visited and there was speculation about the nature of their business and Lizzie's animosity towards him.
19:40 Lizzie and her sister Emma took off for several weeks before the murders, Lizzie rented a room instead of coming back to the house, and both sisters stopped calling their stepmother "mother" around the time their father gave her an extra house.
24:11 Lizzie Borden was seen trying to buy poisonous prusik acid before the murders, but it was ruled inadmissible in court; on the day of the murders, her father was killed with a hatchet while he was sleeping on the sofa, and her stepmother was found dead in the bedroom with her head split open; Lizzie was the only person in the house at the time of the murders.
28:40 Lizzie Borden was indicted for murder after being caught burning a stained dress three days after the murders, and the prosecution used a hatchet head as their main evidence, even though it was never conclusively shown to be the murder weapon and had no blood on it.
33:23 Lizzie Borden's trial had a lot of circumstantial evidence, but no hard evidence or smoking gun, and the police investigation was flawed from the beginning.
38:52 Lizzie Borden was found not guilty of the murders, despite several theories and strange behavior, but there are still doubts about her innocence.
43:41 Lizzie Borden was acquitted of the murders, but she faced social ostracism and died a lonely old woman, despite being buried next to her family members.
48:02 The hosts thank a listener for sharing their perspective on going through life with a certain condition and encourage listeners to share their own fresh perspectives.
Categories: Society & Culture

Browse more Society & Culture