The History of Racialized Policing in America and the Need for Change

TLDR The history of policing in America is deeply rooted in racism and control of marginalized populations, from the slave patrols to the enforcement of Jim Crow laws and the targeting of immigrant and African American communities. The systemic flaws and corruption in the police system highlight the need for a different approach to policing that prioritizes the rights and lives of marginalized populations.

Timestamped Summary

00:00 The podcast explores the history of policing in America and its relationship with the black community, focusing on the use of brutal force to control black Americans.
05:10 The first police forces in America were created to control enslaved Black people, known as slave patrols, which empowered the entire white population to police the movements of Black people.
11:21 Slave patrols, which were responsible for surveilling and punishing enslaved Black people, effectively mobilized not only land owning whites who owned slaves, but also those who didn't, giving them a sense of superiority and control over a whole class of people.
17:34 The South lacked a formal professional police force after the Civil War, leading to the rise of vigilante groups like the Ku Klux Klan that terrorized and controlled black people, prompting the federal government to intervene and eventually leading to the creation of Jim Crow laws; meanwhile, in northern cities, the development of police forces would result in similar experiences of terror for black citizens.
23:22 Early modern policing in the northern US, influenced by the racial hierarchy established by slave patrols in the South, focused on controlling and surveilling immigrant populations, particularly the Irish, and also served as enforcers for political machines and engaged in corruption and violence.
29:32 During the late 19th and early 20th centuries, as labor activism and the Great Migration were taking place, police in northern cities enforced racial norms of white supremacy, participating in violence and discrimination against African Americans and assisting in the enforcement of residential segregation.
35:48 White beachgoers armed themselves and attacked the black community in response to black people demanding justice, leading to several days of violence and self-defense, with the majority of victims being African Americans and the police disproportionately arresting African Americans, revealing a systemic policing problem in northern cities.
41:35 During Prohibition, the police were corrupt and teamed up with mobsters, leading to a display of lawlessness primarily by young white men, which highlighted the systemic flaws and corruption in the police system, leaving black migrants to bear the brunt of the consequences.
47:50 During the period of criminal justice reform that followed Prohibition, the professionalization of police consolidated white ethnic groups into one white race, leaving out the story of racism directed towards black people and perpetuating a sense of identity based on criminality.
53:35 The professionalization of police in the 1930s legitimized racist notions of black people as criminals, and despite decades of evidence and recommendations for change, the problem of police racism and accountability has persisted, leading to the recognition that police agencies are incapable of fixing themselves and requiring a larger societal response.
59:45 The question is whether white people in America prioritize the police protecting their interests over the rights and lives of marginalized populations, and the answer lies in the history of racialized policing and the need for a different political marketplace that rewards a different kind of policing.

Browse more Society & Culture