The Evolution and Impact of Credit Scores on Access to Credit

TLDR Credit scores were created to standardize the credit reporting process and make credit more accessible, but they have also led to discrimination against certain groups. While credit scores have improved access to credit for marginalized groups, they still contribute to unequal interest rates and access to credit.

Timestamped Summary

00:00 Credit scores are numerical rankings of a person's likelihood of paying back debt, and while they were initially intended to make credit more accessible, they now have the power to both open and close doors for individuals.
04:51 Credit scores were created to make credit more transparent and fair, replacing the subjective judgments of individuals with a standardized system, but the algorithms behind credit scores are intentionally obscure to prevent consumers from gaming the system.
10:15 The desire to standardize the credit reporting process in response to social forces and demographics led to the collection of personal information, including race, age, marital status, and occupation, which was used to determine a person's creditworthiness and embedded into credit reports and scores, ultimately making it easier to discriminate against certain groups, such as black Americans.
14:36 The development of credit reporting in the United States was initially promoted as a way to democratize credit access, but it was primarily for white Americans and excluded people of color and women until the civil rights and women's movements in the 1960s and 1970s.
20:32 The development of credit scoring and the rise of credit cards intersected with the civil rights era, leading to changes in credit reporting and scoring to address the exclusion of women and people of color from credit access.
24:58 The development of credit scoring in the 1960s and 1970s was seen as a way to democratize credit and address discrimination, but it became more complicated as variables in credit scoring algorithms could inadvertently discriminate against certain groups, such as using zip code as a proxy for race. However, the introduction of the FICO score in the early 80s allowed for faster and cheaper credit decisions, ultimately leading to increased access to credit for marginalized groups.
29:41 Credit scores, while not perfect, are considered the "gold standard" in terms of reducing discrimination in lending decisions, but they still contribute to unequal interest rates and access to credit for marginalized groups.
34:42 Credit scoring algorithms were developed with the belief that they could eliminate discrimination, but they have not been able to address the disproportionate impact on marginalized groups, and while credit scores are regulated and considered the "gold standard," other algorithms used in decision-making have no limits on the types of information that can be used.
39:06 The formal credit system is designed for people who are part of the mainstream economy, but in order to create a more fair and inclusive credit scoring system, individuals would have to surrender more personal information, leading to increased surveillance, and the current system is run by private corporations whose main concern is protecting businesses, not consumers.
43:33 The credit scoring system treats individuals as representations of a statistical group based on data, which can reproduce discrimination and inequality, and in order to create a more fair and inclusive credit scoring system, it would require reforming both the credit score and the broader economic system.

Browse more Society & Culture