The Concept of Greatness in History: Origins, Evolution, and Controversies

TLDR The concept of greatness in history has its origins in ancient Persian culture and was popularized by Victorian writers. It has evolved over time and is now tied to moral qualities and the ability to lead towards a better future. However, the idea of greatness is contested and tied to notions of national identity, with different models of greatness being rejected or embraced in different countries.

Timestamped Summary

00:00 The first episode of "The Rest is History" podcast discusses the concept of greatness and its origins in Persian culture, with a focus on figures like Alexander the Great and the Persian kings.
03:35 The concept of greatness originated in ancient history and was popularized by Victorian writers, often associated with nation building and state builders, but the term "great" is not typically used for figures in republics like George Washington.
07:00 In democracies, it is rare to call someone "great" because the term is typically associated with monarchs, and in a democracy, the idea of greatness goes against the principles of egalitarianism.
10:22 In the modern world, there is a conflict between the inherent desire to acknowledge and prostrate oneself before the idea of greatness and the reluctance to express it, which is present in republics, democracies, and communist states alike.
13:54 The meaning of greatness has evolved over time, with the classical sense being someone like Churchill who saves his country in a time of crisis, but now there is a greater emphasis on moral greatness, which is why Churchill's flaws are highlighted and he is seen as not measuring up.
17:51 The concept of greatness is contested and tied to notions of national identity, with Churchill being seen as the archetypal poster boy for British greatness, but his model of greatness is now being rejected as militarist and supremacist, reflecting a shift towards a more moral understanding of greatness.
21:56 The concept of greatness is often dismissed by academic historians, but it is still a topic of debate and fascination, particularly in sports and popular culture, with figures like Muhammad Ali and Maradona creating their own myths of greatness; however, when it comes to historical figures, the idea of greatness is often tied to moral qualities and the ability to transcend one's time and lead others towards a better future, resembling the qualities traditionally associated with saints.
25:18 Vladimir Putin may be remembered as "the Great" in Russia due to his ability to create his own reality and model of Russian history, following in the footsteps of great leaders like Catherine the Great and Peter the Great, and transforming his country in a way that garners respect and admiration from Russians.
28:37 Angela Merkel has a claim on the meaning of the word "great" due to her role in opening the borders, but not on the model of greatness seen in leaders like Frederick the Great, as Germany rejects that tradition.
Categories: History

Browse more History