Controversies and Triumphs in the History of the World Cup

TLDR From Germany's surprising victory over Hungary in 1954 to Argentina's controversial win in 1978, the World Cup has been marked by political turmoil, moral ambivalences, and bitter rivalries. Despite the controversies, the tournament has also showcased the triumphs of nations and the power of football to unite and shape national identities.

Timestamped Summary

00:00 The Germans, led by manager Sepp Herberger, participate in the 1954 World Cup after being brought back into FIFA by the English FA, and ultimately defeat Hungary in the final, despite Hungary being the favored team.
05:33 Germany defeats Hungary in the 1954 World Cup final, causing the Hungarian team to become villains and leading to the end of Hungary as a force in soccer, while the victory is celebrated in Germany, with some fans singing the National Anthem but refusing to sing the new words and the president of the German Football Association holding a celebration in a Munich beer hall associated with the Nazis.
10:20 The German papers try to distance themselves from the inflammatory speech made by Baubens, but the damage is already done, with East German papers accusing Germany of steering the same course as Hitler and the British media making derogatory comments about the German team.
15:27 The story of Pickles the dog, who found the stolen World Cup trophy, becomes a national hero before tragically dying, and the presence of North Korea in the World Cup is highlighted, with their upset victory over Italy and the special relationship between Middlesbrough and North Korea.
20:28 The 1966 World Cup match between England and Argentina is marred by controversy and bad behavior on both sides, leading to a negative perception of each other's teams.
25:35 The inequality in Brazil has shaped its unique style of football, with a poor underclass providing a pool of talent and centers of wealth mobilizing that talent, and this inequality has also been used to unite the racially and economically disparate country, with the 1970 World Cup team being an emblem of Brazil's modernity and multi-racial identity, despite the country's struggles with inflation and an oppressive army dictatorship in the 1960s.
30:55 The Brazilian football team, including players like Neymar and Tiago Silva, who come from both poor and rich backgrounds, often support right-wing ideologies like Bolsonaro, which can be attributed to their aspirational and conservative nature as successful footballers.
35:45 The World Cup is fascinating because it is intertwined with moral ambivalences, such as the association of Brazil's triumph in 1970 with the oppressive regime that lasted for another 15 years, and the brutal circumstances under which teams like Zaire and Haiti were playing.
40:52 The Dutch team in the 1974 World Cup final against Germany had a deep-seated hatred towards the Germans due to the Second World War, with one player, Wim van Hannegem, having lost his family in a bombing by the Allies, and despite their early lead, the Dutch lost the match and still hold bitterness towards the Germans to this day.
45:44 The 1978 World Cup in Argentina was held during a time of political turmoil and human rights abuses, with the military dictatorship investing heavily in infrastructure and using the tournament as a means of distraction and propaganda.
50:59 Argentina wins a controversial match against Peru in the 1978 World Cup, with rumors of political interference and bribery, but ultimately goes on to win the tournament by defeating the Netherlands 3-1 in extra time.
55:57 The prisoners in Buenos Aires during the 1978 World Cup realized that the public cared more about football than their own suffering, as the torturers celebrated the victory with their victims and even took some of them out to see the celebrations and have pizza, highlighting the emotional isolation experienced by those who are marginalized and forgotten.
Categories: History

Controversies and Triumphs in the History of the World Cup

The World Cup: Post-war reconciliation, Brazilian dictatorship, and North Koreans in Middlesbrough
by The Rest Is History

Browse more History